Unforgettable Scenes #3: Code Unknown

Michael Haneke’s Code Unknown is a series of interrelated vignettes in the lives of people affected by an outburst of violence in the streets of Paris. It consists of several scenes, all separated by a few seconds of blackness, and almost all shot in just one take per scene. Every single scene is absolutely utterly magnificent and powerfully directed and acted.

To pick just one scene from this movie to focus on for this week’s Unforgettable Scenes is a very difficult choice in itself, but the scene that always sticks with me is the penultimate scene, which sees the character of Anne (Juliette Binoche) sitting on a subway train and being harrassed by an Arab youth. The scene lasts five minutes, and contains more raw and unbearable tension than most directors could put into a whole movie. Haneke’s choice to use a static camera is masterful, and the power of this technique is infused into the five-minute shot, a scene few will be able to easily forget.

The film’s main theme is racial tension, and many of the scenes contain it. This is probably the most racially charged of all the scenes, as the Arab youth makes fun of Binoche’s upper-class white status, attempting to humiliate her for no particular reason other than she looks rich and pompous. In reality, she is not. Throughout the film, she is haunted by the realization that a child that lives in the apartment next to her is being physically – perhaps even sexually – abused. There is one absolutely cold and terrifying scene where we see Binoche doing her clothes ironing and hearing the screams and shouts of children in pain coming from the next room. Even though we see nothing, the scene itself feels unbearable to watch.

The subway scene, my favourite scene in the film, is perhaps the most tense scene in any movie ever. The tension is unbelievable, as is the way Haneke distances us from the terrible abuse Binoche is suffering. Right up till the end, this scene holds us and terrifies us. The scariest thing is that things like this happen all the time, and if we’re sitting in a train, we make nothing of it. Well, here Haneke is forcing us to watch it, and confront the fact that society is an amoral beast, preying on the innocent and holding them in its grip. There is no happy ending here.

Watch the scene for yourself:


Posted on March 26, 2012, in Movies, Unforgettable Scenes and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. Talk about awkward. I personal don’t think i’ve had an experience like that on a train…and hopefully i never will

    • It’s disgusting when things like this happen. It really is. Unfortunately, in film not a lot of attention is payed to small acts of evil like this. Haneke captures it perfectly, as he does in many other scenes of CODE UNKNOWN. The worst thing to do in a situation like the one in that scene is ignore it and don’t try to help. Ironically, that’s exactly what Binoche does in a similar (and equally scary) scene from earlier in the film (this was the other scene I was thinking about choosing for this week’s Unforgettable Scene):

  2. This makes me ambivalent about going to Paris, although I do like a little adventure sometimes. That scene makes it even seem more dangerous than Manila. It’s like the Kitty Genovese syndrome, being witness to these societal horrors but at that time, they were also afraid what the teenager could do to them.

    Although I’d say that no one is really innocent, at least like Binoche’s character, carrying prejudices of her own. Thankfully Benichou (he was in Amelie?) comes to her rescue and speaking of which, I love how these three actors reunite in Cache.

    • I’d like to go to Paris, though I loathe most forms of public transportation, including the “subway”.

      It is clever how Haneke brought back all three actors for Cache. I like to think that Benichou is playing the exact same character in both films. And yes, he was in Amelie.

      • Subways are awesome. If you ride the 6 in New York, which was J.Lo’s train before she went famous, there would be buskers singing for you. There was also a black albino ex-convict who was really nice.

        Back to some real-ish film criticism, I was trying to look for differences between Benichou’s two roles but either way he’s a calmer parent to an angstier generation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: